Skip to content
LGM Roofing Contractors logo
Roof Health

10 signs it’s time for a roof check

If you spot any of these on your North Jersey home, get a free estimate before small damage becomes a five-figure interior repair.

Why this matters

Small damage becomes big damage, fast.

Most of the expensive roof failures we're called out to fix started as one of the ten warning signs below — caught six months earlier, they would have been a repair, not a replacement, or a five-figure water-damage claim.

If you spot any of these on your home, request a free estimate. We’ll come out, take photos of every problem area, and give you a straight answer — even if the answer is “you’ve got another five years, no work needed today.”

  1. 01

    Missing shingles exposing the underlayment

    After a Nor'easter or high-wind event, missing shingles are the most obvious red flag. Once the black underlayment is exposed, your roof deck is one heavy rain away from taking on water — and interior damage starts fast.

    When to worry: Any missing shingle needs a same-week repair before the next storm.

  2. 02

    Cracked shingles from UV overexposure

    New Jersey summers cook asphalt shingles. Over years, UV breaks down the asphalt binder — you'll see hairline splits, curled edges, or shingles that snap when flexed. Cracked shingles no longer seal to the layer below and start losing wind resistance.

    When to worry: Widespread cracking on a 15+ year old roof usually means it's time to plan a replacement.

  3. 03

    Improper prior installation

    You inherit whatever the last roofer did. Common install mistakes we still find: missing ice-and-water shield at eaves, exposed nail heads, wrong nail placement, poor valley detailing, and no starter strip. These roofs look fine for a year, then fail suddenly.

    When to worry: If your last roof went in for a suspiciously low price, get a second opinion before it fails.

  4. 04

    General aging (20+ years old)

    A typical asphalt shingle roof in North Jersey lasts 25–30 years. If yours was installed in the early 2000s or earlier, it's approaching end-of-life whether or not you see obvious damage yet — granules loosen, sealing strips fail, deck attachment weakens.

    When to worry: At 20 years, budget for replacement. At 25+, plan it before winter.

  5. 05

    Fallen limbs on the roof

    A fallen branch might not puncture through, but the impact will crack shingles, dent flashing, and dislodge the granule layer at the strike point. Damage often looks minor from the ground and is only visible from the roof itself.

    When to worry: Any impact from a limb larger than your wrist warrants a professional inspection.

  6. 06

    Foliage in prolonged contact with the roof

    Tree branches that rub against your roof act like slow-motion sandpaper — wearing off protective granules, snagging shingles loose, and shedding moisture-holding leaves into your gutters and valleys.

    When to worry: Any branch touching the roof needs to be trimmed back at least 6 feet.

  7. 07

    Rooftop ice dams in winter

    Ice dams form when heat escapes into the attic, melts snow at the ridge, and the runoff refreezes at the cold eaves. Trapped water backs up under shingles and into your walls. In North Jersey, this is almost always an attic insulation and ventilation problem — not just a roof problem.

    When to worry: If you've had ice dams two winters in a row, we should inspect insulation and ventilation together.

  8. 08

    Moss or algae growth on shingles

    The dark streaks are usually gloeocapsa algae; the fuzzy green patches are moss. Both hold moisture against the shingle surface, accelerate granule loss, and eventually pry shingle edges up as the moss root system grows.

    When to worry: Moss on the north-facing slope of a 15+ year old roof usually means it's time to plan a replacement, not clean and hope.

  9. 09

    Granules in your gutters

    Those coarse black or gray specks in your downspouts and gutters are the protective ceramic granules that keep sunlight off your shingles' asphalt base. A little post-install granule loss is normal; a lot — enough that the gutter looks like coarse sandpaper — means the shingles are wearing out.

    When to worry: Heavy granule loss after a rain, or shingles that look shiny/bald from the ground, mean replacement is close.

  10. 10

    Interior water stains on ceilings or walls

    By the time you see a stain inside the house, water has already been intruding for a while — usually through failed flashing around a chimney, skylight, plumbing vent, or valley. The leak point is rarely directly above the stain.

    When to worry: Don't sit on an active leak. Call today — we can tarp it while we schedule the real repair.

What to do next

Spot one? Get a free estimate.

A 20-year GAF Master Elite® contractor comes out, walks the roof, takes photos of every problem area, and hands you a written report — whether the answer is a repair, a claim, a maintenance plan, or nothing at all. No pressure. No pushy sales.

Free Estimate · No Pressure

Active leak? Emergency tarping available.

Call (973) 707-2154 and we'll get a tarp on it while we schedule the permanent repair. After-hours calls are returned first thing the next morning.